Hitchcock is now my ALL TIME FAVORITE director!!!
I think I have watched every single movie he has ever made. A heavy dose over only a couple of weeks. What else can I do anyway. I had planned to write a *detailed* review for each Hitchcock movie I watched, but I just don’t have the time, or the desire, or both. I will only jot down the things that impressed me the most. This post will be updated whenever I have new thoughts.
Rebecca (1940)
With extraordinary mastery of the language and keen perception of the human soul, Daphne Du Maurier crafted a thrilling story of love and intrigue. It begins with a breezy, almost comic whirlwind Cinderella romance when the inexperienced, poor but sweet girl met Mr. de Winter, an English gentleman with power, money, reputation, mystery, and a mercurial personality. Things began falling apart when the newly weds went home to the legendary Mandeley, and all hell broke loose when *THE MRS DE WINTER* first wife Rebecca’s body was found on the bottom of the ocean when it was supposed to be in the family grave. The finale was utterly gut-wrenching, yet triumphant.
I kept comparing the movie with the book as I was watching. By itself it is a really fine piece of work. The story unfolds smoothly. One gets hints at even the funniest moment that something sinister was lurking somewhere, waiting to prance upon the poor unsuspecting girl. The vast mansion, every inch of it deeply submerged in the haunting memories, can make the sanest person claustrophobic. Joan Fontaine was perfect for the role of the second Mrs. De Winter: innocent, sweet, honest and sincere, devoted, kind and unassuming, modest to the degree of timid, a bit jumpy, unconfident and unsure at times but can be tough when cornered (“I am Mrs. De Winter now!”). The only problem I have is the opening monolog, where she (supposedly in her old age) reminisced about the story of Rebecca and Mandeley. The voice is not at all what I had imagined. It is too loud, stiff, and high-pitched. This is not the voice I would choose for her. I wouldn’t want to deal with a woman like Mrs. Danvers. She is probably the scariest looking lady I have ever seen. Always pale (well they are all pale in the B&W film but I am sure she was paler than others) and expressionless, speaking in a sly hypnotizing monotone, she was more vampire than vampire (although in Anne Rice’s world, vampires are the most artistic, debonair and fatally charismatic individuals). I suspect she was a lesbian madly in love with Rebecca, but I could be wrong. My biggest regret is that this movie is B&W. I really want to see Mandeley in colors, and it wouldn’t kill to show the blue of the sea. Those elaborately exquisite descriptions of Mandeley in the book are utterly wasted in this movie.
Like many of other Hitchcock’s works, this is a movie worth savoring, over and over again.
Vertigo (1958)
This is a master piece. I don’t know if Hitchcock was the first one that used abstract images and dramatic colors to express the anguish of a nightmare, and honestly I don’t care. Those spiraling and fragmented patterns and colors are just brilliant. Half way through the story, I was led to believe that this would be another Hitchcock “psycho thrillers” (the kind that deals with a tormented human mind, like Spellbound, Psycho, Marnie, Suspicion, etc.), where Madeleine was insane and Scottie was the one to cure her. But it completely changed when she supposedly plunged to her death. Unlike the many modern so-called suspense stories that become too obvious in the first 15 minutes, it totally baffled me until the finale. The permeating gloom throughout the movie kept me at the edge of my seat at all times. There wasn’t any of the typical Hitchcock comic dialog or morbid humor. Everything was mysterious, and tragic.
My only gripe was the ending. It’s too perfect: Judy got what she deserved (being scared by a nun is something like being punished by God), and Scottie was spared the moral dilemma between love and justice. It’s just too neat, too fatalistic. Is there a better alternative ending? Should they stop at their embrace, get a close-up of Scottie’s eyes, and let audiences do the guess work?
No matter what, this is one of my favorite Hitchcock movies.
Frenzy (1972)
Touted as Hitchcock’s best “later” works after his peak was over in the 60s, it is one of the few movies that I dozed off in the middle, partly because it is actually kind of boring, and partly because I watched it after lunch and my blood was busy working for my stomach instead of my brain. It is also way too long. I still prefer the neat short works.
The most shocking element of this movie that remains the talk of today, is definitely the rape scene. I have not felt so nauseated since I watched a similar (but of course, much longer, and more graphic) scene in Irreversible. I can’t believe they would show it in the 70s! Have they done some special makeup for Rusk the Killer? His skin was of such sickish yellow color that he looked like a terminal Hepatitis patient!
The highlight (of the part I was awake at least) was undoubtedly the “looking for his pin in the potato truck” scene. It is one of the funniest (morbidly) and memorable scenes ever. The comic elements (foot in the face, the finger breaking, etc.) and the suspense whether he would be caught were so perfectly blended that I at first laughed, and then breathed a sigh of relief when he got out of the car, undiscovered. MY GOD!!! I felt relieved that he was not caught?!! This is insane – I was so absorbed that I *was* Rusk for a brief moment! Such is the magic of Hitchcock movies – you totally forget who you are and gasp and scream with the roles, be them victims or killers. I knew I shouldn’t laugh at the grisly scene where he fumbled around the body but I just couldn’t stop laughing, and I believed Hitchcock intended it to be funny. Barry Forster was utterly believable in the role and deserved an award of some sort.
Notorious (1946)
One of the “cult classics”, it has a star-studded cast (Cary Grant and Ingrid Bergman) and a perfect blend of romance and espionage intrigue. For some odd reason, I didn’t have strong feelings for this movie. I enjoyed the story, but found it hard to understand Devlin and Alicia. Honestly, I think Claude Raines outshined the others as the ruthless, cunning, temporarily love-blinded Alex Sebastian.
The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956)
I only watched the American version but there is an earlier version made in 1934. Not his best, but nonetheless extremely enjoyable. That clang of the cymbal and the scream of Doris Day were just as memorable as the screeching violin at the shower scene of Psycho.
Rope (1948)
This movie tells an interesting story that can be great material for a stage play, and I suspect a play might even be better.
39 Steps (1935)
Hitchcock’s first “spy movie”, and the second “old” Hitchcock movie I saw. I watched Rebecca, Psycho, Vertigo, Rear Window, and The Man Who Knew Too Much many years ago but my recent Hitchcock Extravaganza was actually sparked by Stranger on the Train, and fueled by 39 Steps. I used to think watching B&W was kind of silly, like those bored people on TV who had nothing else to do on weekends and dozed off watching old movies. But Hitchcock totally changed my perception of B&W movies. Even though primitive in many ways (mostly the “action” part, according to today’s standard), this movie still shines with an excellent plot, delightful performance, witty dialog, intelligent quips, some kind of light-hearted romance, and a surprising finale. These elements are used repeatedly and expanded in Hitchcock’s later works.
Some of the lines are so brilliant that I have to list them here:
* The political speech Hannay made at the gathering when he was misidentified as a Senator (not sure if it’s really “senator”, just some kind of important figure). The way he stalled and talked bullshit (I wonder if those lines were deliberately written to convey sarcasm at politics and politicians) got me laughing till my tummy hurt. To top it off, when he couldn’t stall anymore and was escorted away by his captors, he said: “what took you so long?” as if he was accusing them of their incompetence. Just brilliant.
* All the banter between Hannay and Pamela. It’s almost like a romantic comedy, only with wit instead of stupidity (like the many r.c. these days).
* The finale: at the verge of death, Mr. Memory told the truth and sighed in relief: “finally, I don’t have to remember any more.”
* The road was blocked by a flock of sheep and Hannay commented “A whole flock of detectives”.
This is my FAVORITE Hitchcock movie.
North by Northwest (1959)
Although raking in much higher ratings than 39 Steps, this movie is almost like a “franchised sequel” (like those of 007, only with a different leading man) to the later. There are plenty of similar elements although NBN is much more somber in its tone and more complicated. The plot is full of twists and turns that keep you guessing till the end.
The most memorable scenes: Thornhill being chased by a “crop-dusting plane”, and the cat-and-mouse on Mount Rushmore.
The funniest scene: at the auction where Thornhill was being deliberately disruptive so that he could be arrested by the police.
The funniest line: “I’ve got a job, a secretary, a mother, two ex-wives and several bartenders dependent on me, and I don’t intend to disappoint them all and get myself slightly killed!” (Thornhill)
Again, one of my favorites (Aggghhh, how many favorites can I have?!).
Stranger on a Train (1951)
My first “early” Hitchcock movie and I wholeheartedly love it. Robert Walker was smashingly brilliant as the suave manipulative psycho that can bring you the worst nightmares if you are fooled by his gentle smile and sleek appearance. Faley Granger was a cute guy but why was he always playing the skittish and nervous suckers (he was the “weak” guy in Rope)?
The most memorable scene: final showdown at the carousal.
Funniest line: “Oh, Daddy doesn’t mind a little scandal. He’s a senator”
It really got me interested in Patricia Highsmith’s works.
Spellbound (1945)
A great psychological thriller. I will never forget the word “guilt complex” after watching this movie, and will never forget the J.B./Dr. Brulov night scene (where J.B. came down the stairs, staring at Dr. Brulov impassively, razor in hand, looked through the glass bottom at the old man, and the “body” of Brulov on the chair the next morning). I actually thought the old guy was killed! Great twist!
The classic lines:
* “Women make the best psychoanalysts until they fall in love. After that they make the best patients.”
* “There is nothing so nice as a new marriage. No psychosis yet, no regressions, no guilt complexes”
Lifeboat (1944)
A very unique and intriguing film. Half-way through the movie I thought: “now this is ground-breaking – picturing a *good* German in those days?!” Well, it’s not as simple as that. Eventually the “good” and “competent” German was nothing but an incorrigible Nazi “with a plan”, who knew how to turn the table to his advantage, manipulate the simple-minded, naïve “Christians”, and do whatever it took to ensure his ultimate survival. It is probably one of the most “political” Hitchcock movies.
The roles are well chosen, representing all walks of life and personalities. I am glad they didn’t show the amputation in action. If there were a remake, there would certainly be plenty of gurgling blood and wobbling flesh.
Rear Window (1954)
A man confined by the wheelchair, observing the lives of his neighbors via his window, deducting that a murder took place. Is it real, or is it the over active imagination of a man craving for action but unfortunately couldn’t get any?
Undoubtedly a masterpiece, this movie packs a large dose of humor and witty dialog that has become his trademark over the years, never-ceasing suspense that is his signature, a somewhat cheesy romance that I find more funny than romantic, and a unique angle to look at a crime. It has probably the best screenplay among all his movies.
Funny scene: Watcher-turned-watchee Jeff using the flash to fend off the approaching killer.
Memorable quotes:
“Intelligence. Nothing has caused the human race so much trouble as intelligence” (Stella)
“We’ve become a race of Peeping Toms. What people ought to do is get outside their own house and look in for a change. Yes sir. How’s that for a bit of homespun philosophy?” (Stella)
“Jeff, you know if someone came in here, they wouldn’t believe what they’d see? You and me with long faces plunged into despair because we find out a man didn’t kill his wife. We’re two of the most frightening ghouls I’ve ever known” (Lisa)
Gunderson: It’s about time you got married, before you turn into a lonesome and bitter old man.
Jeff: Yeah, can’t you just see me, rushing home to a hot apartment to listen to the automatic laundry and the electric dishwasher and the garbage disposal and the nagging wife…
Gunderson: Jeff, wives don’t nag anymore. They discuss. (** I love the humor)
Jeff: Oh, is that so, is that so? Well, maybe in the high-rent district they discuss. In my neighborhood they still nag.
Jeff: Would you fix me a sandwich, please?
Stella: Yes, I will. And I’ll spread a little common sense on the bread.
“Eleven hundred? They ought to list that dress on the stock exchange.” (Jeff)
Jeff: She sure is the “eat, drink and be merry” girl.
Stella:Yeah, she’ll wind up fat, alcoholic and miserable.
And many more from Andy’s Movie Quote Page.
Psycho (1960)
Possibly the most famous Hitchcock movie and deservedly so. I wonder if it ruined the motel business when it was first released. At least personally, it keeps haunting me for many years to come, because whenever I see or think of a motel I would think of the famous (infamous) Bate’s Motel, whenever I see a clean cut young man behind the motel front desk, I would think of the psycho, whenever I take a shower in the hotel/motel room, I would double check that the deadbolt is in place on the front door. And the shower scene music, Aaaagggghhhh! It sends a chill up my spine just writing about it!
Shadow of a Doubt (1943)
Not a very famous movie, it is still a masterpiece with outstanding performance. If not for the silly actions the girl took after she was certain of her uncle’s crime (not telling the detective and confronting him – how can you even think of talking sense to a psychopath?!), I would rate it as one of the best Hitchcock classics! The suspense was killing me from the very beginning because I knew Uncle Charlie was the psycho: when will Niece Charlie find out, how will she react, will she tell, what will happen to her if she doesn’t tell, how will this mess end?The finale is very similar to that of Vertigo, a convenient “God sent” revenge.
Teresa was excellent in playing the smart Niece Charlie, portraying the fine-tuned changes from her unconditional adoration for her uncle at the beginning, to nagging suspicion when she learned the truth, to anger and fear after Uncle Charlie slipped the net of justice, to resolution and intelligence in the end when she realized she had to do sth to drive him out without hurting her mother (a doting elder sister to UC). Joseph Cotten was also great playing the sinister, calculating, self-righteous, cold-blooded killer (most villains in Hitchcock movies were the “self-righteous” type). The clueless garrulous mother drove me crazy by the way. The actor playing the detective Jack Gramm looked like a young Kevin Costner.
The Lady Vanishes (1938)
Another romantic comedy/thriller and highly entertaining. Although it is not particularly famous, I love it dearly.
The most memorable scene:
Iris and Gilbert scrambling among the luggage looking for evidence that Mrs. Froy existed. They saw a box moving and thought the old lady was trapped there, only to find out that it was a goat!! During the fight with the intruder, the expressions (if you can call the looks “expressions”) and actions (watching intently at first and promptly hid away when it got rough) of rabbits and the goat added great comic moments.
The gun fight: fairly primitive according to today’s standard, but still enjoyable.
For some reason, I really like the shot of the simpering Italian who sat by Mrs. Froy. His smile gave me goose bumps.
The Hitchcock Formula
Guess this topic is beaten to death over the years, and with his productive career, it’s hard to whip out a few points and put this great director in the box. However, I feel compelled to spell out a few musings of my own.
Three Major Types
Psycho-thriller
Espionage/spy thriller
Romantic thriller
Recurring theme
An innocent man wrongfully accused of a crime and put into a difficult position but was resourceful enough to get out of it eventually, after much high adventure, often aided (sometimes reluctantly at first) by a charming lady. They eventually fell in love after the ordeal.
Obsession
Hitchcock was obsessed with the idea of “the perfect murder”. It was either a main theme (Dial M for Murder, Rope), or a comic relief (Shadow of a Doubt). Inevitably Hitchcock told us that there was no such thing in real life because things always went wrong.
Dramatic music
Great music that holds your breath or makes you scream. However, in his early movies, the music was often way too loud and kind of annoying.
Fashion
The good guys were always charismatic gentlemen with slick impeccable hair (probably the high fashion in those days, unlike the meticulously tousled spikes of today).
The good girls were always dressed impeccably in elegant suites or skirts, unlike the super low-rise jeans and deliberately *casual* tank tops.
Key elements
Humor: sharp observations of life, society, politics.
Romance: most of the time funny and delightful
Action: with unexpected twists and turns
Man vs. Woman
Men were inevitably cool-headed and unfathomable. They could show a poker face even when they were in emotional turmoil.
Women were emotional, often panicked and sometimes became overly dramatic.
His favorite leading man
James Stewart: he had that wise, urbane, slightly mischievious, slightly haunted look that made him a star and a recurring lead in Hitchcock movies. However, if he wanted he could really play a devilish character (I haven’t watched his other movies so maybe he did play a bad guy once), mainly because of his look and his pale blue eyes. He also has a look-alike: Tom Amandes (“Dr. Abbott” in the WB series Everwood).